UNPKG

oneie

Version:

Build apps, websites, and AI agents in English. Zero-interaction setup for AI agents (Claude Code, Cursor, Windsurf). Download to your computer, run in the cloud, deploy to the edge. Open source and free forever.

800 lines (638 loc) 24.6 kB
--- title: Cryptonetworks dimension: connections category: cryptonetworks.md tags: agent, ai, architecture, blockchain, ontology, protocol related_dimensions: events, knowledge, things scope: global created: 2025-11-03 updated: 2025-11-03 version: 1.0.0 ai_context: | This document is part of the connections dimension in the cryptonetworks.md category. Location: one/connections/cryptonetworks.md Purpose: Documents crypto networks - ai agent architecture analysis Related dimensions: events, knowledge, things For AI agents: Read this to understand cryptonetworks. --- # Crypto Networks - AI Agent Architecture Analysis **Version:** 1.0.0 **Status:** Strategic **Purpose:** Identify optimal blockchain networks for AI agent operations with near-zero finality, minimal marginal cost, and parallel execution --- ## Executive Summary **Optimal Architecture: Multi-Chain with SUI Primary** After deep analysis of finality times, marginal costs, parallel execution capabilities, and AI agent ecosystems, the recommended architecture is: 1. **Primary Network: SUI** - Best overall for AI agents 2. **Secondary: Solana** - High-frequency operations 3. **Tertiary: Base (L2)** - Ethereum ecosystem access 4. **Experimental: Aptos** - Move ecosystem diversity **Key Insight:** The ONE Platform's protocol-agnostic ontology makes multi-chain architecture trivial - networks are just metadata. --- ## Evaluation Criteria ### 1. Finality Time (Target: <1 second) Time from transaction submission to irreversible confirmation. ### 2. Marginal Cost (Target: <$0.001/tx) Cost per transaction in steady-state operation. ### 3. Parallel Execution (Critical for AI) Ability to process multiple transactions simultaneously without sequential bottlenecks. ### 4. AI Agent Ecosystem (Critical for Builder Experience) Developer tools, AI-native features, and ecosystem maturity for building autonomous agents. --- ## Network Analysis Matrix ### Tier 1: Optimal for AI Agents #### **SUI - RECOMMENDED PRIMARY** **Finality:** ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (400-500ms) - Single-shot consensus with Byzantine Fault Tolerant (BFT) protocol - Transactions finalized in <1 second - No probabilistic finality - instant and deterministic **Marginal Cost:** ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ($0.0001/tx) - Gas price: ~0.0001 SUI per transaction - At $0.50 SUI price: $0.00005 per transaction - Storage rebates make some operations profit-neutral **Parallel Execution:** ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (TRUE PARALLELISM) - **Object-centric model** - transactions that touch different objects execute in parallel - **No global state lock** - massive throughput scaling - **Move language** - compiler-enforced safety prevents race conditions - Theoretical throughput: 297,000 TPS (observed: 65,000+ TPS on testnet) **AI Agent Ecosystem:** ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (EXCELLENT) - **Move language**: More deterministic than Solidity, easier for AI to reason about - **Object model**: Maps perfectly to ONE ontology (objects = entities) - **Programmable transaction blocks**: Complex multi-step operations in single transaction - **Sponsored transactions**: AI agents can pay gas for users - **ZK Login**: Seamless onboarding with Web2 credentials - **TypeScript SDK**: `@mysten/sui.js` - first-class TypeScript support - **Growing ecosystem**: DeepBook (orderbook DEX), Aftermath, Turbos **Why SUI Wins:** ```typescript // SUI's object model is PERFECT for the ontology // Each entity is a unique object with guaranteed uniqueness struct CreatorToken has key, store { id: UID, supply: u64, creator: address, // Maps directly to entity properties } // Parallel execution means: // - User A buys tokens → Transaction 1 // - User B stakes tokens → Transaction 2 // Both execute simultaneously without conflicts! ``` **Downsides:** - Newer network (launched 2023) - less battle-tested - Smaller ecosystem than Solana/Ethereum - Learning curve for Move language **Verdict:** 🏆 **PRIMARY NETWORK** - Best overall for AI agents building on the ONE Platform. **Creator Token Rollout (2025 Update)** - `creator_token` smart contracts map 1:1 to SUI Move objects; treasury caps live as things with `properties.network = "sui"` and `properties.coinType`. - Programmable Transaction Blocks let CreatorOS mint, vest, and stream tokens (membership, revenue share) atomically while AI agents sponsor gas. - Storage rebates + object-centric parallelism keep millions of fan wallets cheap to maintain; balances sync into the ONE ontology via `holds_tokens` connections. - ZK Login + Sponsored Transactions mean fans claim creator tokens instantly using email/Social without touching seed phrases—perfect for mainstream onboarding. --- #### **Solana** **Finality:** ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (400ms) - Single slot confirmation (~400ms) - Deterministic finality after 32 slots (~12 seconds for economic finality) - Optimistic finality is enough for most AI operations **Marginal Cost:** ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ($0.00025/tx) - 0.000005 SOL per transaction - At $50 SOL price: $0.00025 per transaction - Priority fees can increase cost during congestion **Parallel Execution:** ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (TRUE PARALLELISM) - **Sealevel runtime** - parallel transaction processing - Transactions declare accounts they'll touch (like SUI objects) - Non-overlapping transactions execute in parallel - Proven at scale: 65,000 TPS observed **AI Agent Ecosystem:** ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (MATURE) - **Largest AI/ML ecosystem** in crypto - AI-generated art (Solana NFTs), AI trading bots, AI DeFi - **Rust programs** - performant, safe, AI-friendly - **Anchor framework** - simplified development - **Web3.js / @solana/web3.js** - excellent TypeScript support - **Helius, Triton** - enhanced RPC for AI indexing - **Jito** - MEV infrastructure for AI trading agents - **Geyser plugins** - real-time data streams for AI **Why Solana Is Strong:** ```rust // Solana's account model with parallel execution pub fn process_instruction( program_id: &Pubkey, accounts: &[AccountInfo], instruction_data: &[u8], ) -> ProgramResult { // AI agent declares accounts upfront // Solana scheduler parallelizes non-conflicting txs // Perfect for high-frequency AI trading/operations } ``` **Downsides:** - Periodic network congestion (improving with Firedancer) - Account rent (storage costs) - Occasional downtime historically (rare now) **Verdict:** 🥈 **SECONDARY NETWORK** - Best for high-frequency AI operations, mature ecosystem. --- #### **Aptos** **Finality:** ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (<1 second) - Block-STM consensus - Sub-second finality - BFT guarantees **Marginal Cost:** ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ($0.0001-0.001/tx) - Gas price varies but generally very low - At current APT prices: ~$0.0005/tx **Parallel Execution:** ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (BLOCK-STM) - **Block-STM** - Software Transactional Memory - Optimistic parallel execution with conflict detection - Re-executes conflicting transactions sequentially - Theoretical: 160,000+ TPS **AI Agent Ecosystem:** ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (GROWING) - **Move language** - same as SUI (slight dialect differences) - **Strong typing** - AI agents can reason about code safety - **Parallel execution** - great for AI swarms - Smaller ecosystem than SUI/Solana but growing - Good developer experience **Why Aptos Is Interesting:** - Move language diversity (fallback if SUI has issues) - Block-STM is theoretically superior to SUI's object model for some use cases - Strong VC backing (a16z, FTX pre-collapse) **Downsides:** - Smaller ecosystem than SUI/Solana - Less differentiated from SUI - FTX association (historical concern) **Verdict:** 🥉 **EXPERIMENTAL** - Backup Move network, worth watching. --- ### Tier 2: Good But Compromised #### **Base (Ethereum L2)** **Finality:** ⭐⭐⭐ (1-2 seconds soft, 7 days hard) - Optimistic rollup - instant soft finality - 7-day challenge period for hard finality (withdrawals) - Soft finality is fine for most operations **Marginal Cost:** ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ($0.001-0.01/tx) - Depends on Ethereum L1 gas prices - Typically $0.001-0.01 per transaction - Can spike during congestion **Parallel Execution:** ⭐ (NO - Sequential EVM) - Standard EVM - sequential execution - Transactions process one-by-one - Major bottleneck for AI agent swarms **AI Agent Ecosystem:** ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (MASSIVE) - **Largest ecosystem** - Ethereum compatibility - Coinbase backing - enterprise-grade infrastructure - **Thirdweb, Alchemy, QuickNode** - excellent AI tooling - **OpenZeppelin** - battle-tested contracts - **Huge DeFi ecosystem** - Uniswap, Aave, etc. - AI agent frameworks: Langchain integrations, GPT-4 code generation **Why Base Matters:** ```solidity // EVM = Sequential execution (bad for parallelism) // But huge ecosystem (good for integrations) contract AIAgent { // Familiar Solidity - lots of AI training data // Tons of libraries, tooling, examples // Easy for AI to generate/audit code } ``` **Downsides:** - **No parallel execution** - deal breaker for high-throughput AI - Sequential bottleneck - Higher costs than SUI/Solana **Verdict:** 🔗 **BRIDGE NETWORK** - Use for Ethereum ecosystem access, not primary AI operations. --- #### **NEAR Protocol** **Finality:** ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (1-2 seconds) - Nightshade sharding - ~1-2 second finality **Marginal Cost:** ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ($0.0001/tx) - Extremely low gas fees - ~$0.0001 per transaction **Parallel Execution:** ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (SHARDED) - Multiple shards process transactions in parallel - Not as granular as SUI's object model - Good throughput **AI Agent Ecosystem:** ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (AI-FOCUSED) - **NEAR AI** - official AI initiative - Focus on AI + blockchain convergence - Rust + AssemblyScript - good for AI - Smaller ecosystem than top tier **Downsides:** - Less proven than Solana - Sharding complexity - Smaller DeFi ecosystem **Verdict:****ALTERNATIVE** - Strong AI focus, worth considering. --- ### Tier 3: Specialized Use Cases #### **Monad** (Launching 2024) **Finality:** ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (~1 second) - Optimized consensus **Marginal Cost:** ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (Target: <$0.001/tx) - Designed for ultra-low cost **Parallel Execution:** ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (PARALLEL EVM) - **MonadBFT** - optimistic parallel execution - EVM-compatible but parallel - 10,000 TPS target **AI Agent Ecosystem:** ⭐⭐ (NEW) - Not launched yet - Promises EVM compatibility + parallelism - Could be game-changer if delivered **Verdict:** 🔮 **FUTURE** - Watch closely, could disrupt if EVM + parallelism works. --- #### **Avalanche** **Finality:** ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (1-2 seconds) - Avalanche consensus - very fast - Sub-2-second finality **Marginal Cost:** ⭐⭐⭐ ($0.01-0.1/tx) - Higher than SUI/Solana - C-Chain (EVM) is more expensive **Parallel Execution:** ⭐⭐⭐ (SUBNETS) - Subnets can run in parallel - Not transaction-level parallelism **AI Agent Ecosystem:** ⭐⭐⭐ (MODERATE) - Good DeFi ecosystem - Subnet flexibility - Smaller AI focus **Verdict:** 🏔️ **NICHE** - Good for subnets, not optimal for AI agents. --- ## Recommended Architecture ### Multi-Chain Strategy The ONE Platform's protocol-agnostic ontology enables seamless multi-chain support: ```typescript // Same entity across all networks - just metadata changes { type: "token", name: "Creator Token", properties: { // Network-agnostic properties symbol: "CREATOR", totalSupply: 1_000_000, // Network-specific properties deployments: { sui: { network: "sui", packageId: "0x123...", coinType: "0x123::token::CREATOR", }, solana: { network: "solana", mintAddress: "ABC123...", programId: "DEF456...", }, base: { network: "base", contractAddress: "0xabc...", chainId: 8453, }, }, }, } // Events track cross-chain { type: "tokens_purchased", metadata: { network: "sui", // or "solana", "base" // Network-specific details }, } ``` ### Network Allocation Strategy **SUI (Primary - 70% of operations)** - Token launches - NFT minting - Creator staking - AI agent coordination - Complex multi-step operations **Solana (Secondary - 20% of operations)** - High-frequency trading bots - AI agent swarms (thousands of micro-transactions) - Real-time price oracles - Gaming/metaverse integrations **Base (Bridge - 10% of operations)** - Ethereum DeFi access - USDC payments (native on Base) - Enterprise integrations - Fiat on/off ramps **Why This Works:** - SUI handles bulk of operations (cheap, fast, parallel) - Solana handles high-frequency edge cases - Base provides Ethereum ecosystem bridge - Effect.ts abstraction means frontends don't care which chain --- ## Implementation Guide ### 1. Multi-Chain Provider Layer ```typescript // convex/services/providers/blockchain.ts import { Effect, Layer } from "effect"; import { SuiClient } from "@mysten/sui/client"; import { Connection } from "@solana/web3.js"; import { createPublicClient, http } from "viem"; import { base } from "viem/chains"; export class BlockchainProvider extends Effect.Service<BlockchainProvider>()( "BlockchainProvider", { effect: Effect.gen(function* () { // Initialize all network clients const sui = new SuiClient({ url: process.env.SUI_RPC_URL }); const solana = new Connection(process.env.SOLANA_RPC_URL); const baseClient = createPublicClient({ chain: base, transport: http(process.env.BASE_RPC_URL), }); return { // Unified interface - network selection via parameter getBalance: (network: Network, address: string, tokenType?: string) => Effect.gen(function* () { switch (network) { case "sui": return yield* Effect.tryPromise(() => sui.getBalance({ owner: address, coinType: tokenType }) ); case "solana": return yield* Effect.tryPromise(() => solana.getBalance(new PublicKey(address)) ); case "base": return yield* Effect.tryPromise(() => baseClient.getBalance({ address: address as `0x${string}` }) ); } }), executeTransaction: (network: Network, tx: Transaction) => Effect.gen(function* () { // Network-specific execution logic // Returns normalized result }), subscribeToEvents: (network: Network, filter: EventFilter) => Effect.gen(function* () { // Unified event subscription // Normalizes events to ontology format }), }; }), dependencies: [], } ) {} type Network = "sui" | "solana" | "base"; ``` ### 2. Network Selection Logic ```typescript // convex/services/blockchain/network-selector.ts export class NetworkSelector extends Effect.Service<NetworkSelector>()( "NetworkSelector", { effect: Effect.gen(function* () { return { // Intelligent network selection based on operation type selectOptimalNetwork: (operation: OperationType) => Effect.gen(function* () { switch (operation.type) { case "token_mint": case "nft_mint": case "staking": return "sui"; // Primary for complex operations case "high_frequency_trade": case "micro_transaction": return "solana"; // High-frequency operations case "usdc_payment": case "defi_integration": return "base"; // Ethereum ecosystem access default: return "sui"; // Default to primary } }), // Cost optimization - choose cheapest network for operation selectCheapestNetwork: (operation: OperationType) => Effect.gen(function* () { const costs = yield* Effect.all([ this.estimateCost("sui", operation), this.estimateCost("solana", operation), this.estimateCost("base", operation), ]); const cheapest = costs.reduce((min, curr) => curr.cost < min.cost ? curr : min ); return cheapest.network; }), }; }), } ) {} ``` ### 3. Cross-Chain Bridge Service ```typescript // convex/services/blockchain/bridge.ts export class BridgeService extends Effect.Service<BridgeService>()( "BridgeService", { effect: Effect.gen(function* () { const blockchain = yield* BlockchainProvider; return { // Bridge tokens from SUI to Solana bridgeTokens: (args: BridgeArgs) => Effect.gen(function* () { // 1. Lock on source chain const lockTx = yield* blockchain.executeTransaction( args.sourceNetwork, args.lockTransaction ); // 2. Verify lock (wait for finality) yield* Effect.sleep(500); // SUI finality // 3. Mint on destination chain const mintTx = yield* blockchain.executeTransaction( args.destNetwork, args.mintTransaction ); // 4. Log bridge event yield* Effect.tryPromise(() => db.insert("events", { type: "tokens_bridged", actorId: args.userId, targetId: args.tokenId, timestamp: Date.now(), metadata: { sourceNetwork: args.sourceNetwork, destNetwork: args.destNetwork, sourceTx: lockTx.digest, destTx: mintTx.digest, amount: args.amount, }, }) ); return { success: true, lockTx, mintTx }; }), }; }), dependencies: [BlockchainProvider.Default], } ) {} ``` ### 4. Frontend Network Abstraction ```typescript // src/components/features/tokens/MultiChainTokenPurchase.tsx import { useMutation, useQuery } from "convex/react"; import { api } from "@/convex/_generated/api"; import { Button } from "@/components/ui/button"; import { Select } from "@/components/ui/select"; export function MultiChainTokenPurchase({ tokenId }: Props) { const [network, setNetwork] = useState<"sui" | "solana" | "base">("sui"); const purchase = useMutation(api.tokens.purchase); const balances = useQuery(api.tokens.getAllBalances, { tokenId }); return ( <div> <Select value={network} onValueChange={setNetwork}> <option value="sui">SUI (Fastest, Cheapest) ⚡</option> <option value="solana">Solana (High Frequency) 🚀</option> <option value="base">Base (Ethereum DeFi) 🔗</option> </Select> <div> <p>SUI Balance: {balances?.sui || 0}</p> <p>Solana Balance: {balances?.solana || 0}</p> <p>Base Balance: {balances?.base || 0}</p> </div> <Button onClick={() => purchase({ tokenId, amount: 100, network, // User chooses network }) } > Buy 100 Tokens on {network.toUpperCase()} </Button> </div> ); } ``` --- ## Performance Benchmarks ### Finality Comparison ``` Network | Soft Finality | Hard Finality | Winner -----------------|---------------|---------------|-------- SUI | 400-500ms | 400-500ms | 🏆 Solana | 400ms | ~12s | 🏆 Aptos | <1s | <1s | 🏆 Base | 1-2s | 7 days | ❌ NEAR | 1-2s | 1-2s | ✅ Avalanche | 1-2s | 1-2s | ✅ ``` ### Cost Comparison (per 1,000 transactions) ``` Network | Cost | Winner -----------------|---------------|-------- SUI | $0.05 | 🏆 Solana | $0.25 | 🏆 Aptos | $0.50 | ✅ NEAR | $0.10 | 🏆 Base | $1-10 | ❌ Avalanche | $10-100 | ❌ ``` ### Parallel Execution Throughput ``` Network | TPS (Observed) | Parallel | Winner -----------------|----------------|----------|-------- SUI | 65,000+ | ✅ | 🏆 Solana | 65,000+ | ✅ | 🏆 Aptos | 160,000+ | ✅ | 🏆 Base | ~1,000 | ❌ | ❌ NEAR | ~100,000 | ✅ | 🏆 Monad (target) | 10,000+ | ✅ | 🔮 ``` ### AI Ecosystem Maturity ``` Network | AI Tools | DeFi | NFTs | Developer UX | Winner -----------------|----------|------|------|--------------|-------- SUI | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | 🏆 Solana | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ | 🏆 Base | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | 🏆 Aptos | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ✅ NEAR | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ✅ ``` --- ## Final Recommendation ### Primary Architecture: **SUI-First Multi-Chain** **Network Priority:** 1. **SUI (70%)** - Primary for all standard operations 2. **Solana (20%)** - High-frequency and proven scale 3. **Base (10%)** - Ethereum ecosystem bridge **Why This Architecture Wins:****Near-Zero Finality:** SUI = 400ms, Solana = 400ms ✅ **Minimal Cost:** SUI = $0.00005/tx, Solana = $0.00025/tx ✅ **Parallel Execution:** Both have true parallelism ✅ **AI Ecosystem:** Both have strong AI tooling ✅ **Future-Proof:** Multi-chain from day one ✅ **Protocol-Agnostic:** ONE ontology works across all networks **Implementation Timeline:** **Phase 1 (Month 1-2): SUI Primary** - Deploy core contracts on SUI - Build SUI provider in Effect.ts - Launch token + NFT infrastructure **Phase 2 (Month 3): Solana Secondary** - Port contracts to Solana - Add Solana provider - Enable cross-chain balances **Phase 3 (Month 4): Base Bridge** - Deploy ERC20 wrapper on Base - Build bridge service - Enable USDC payments **Phase 4 (Month 5+): Optimization** - Intelligent network selection - Cost optimization - Cross-chain arbitrage for AI agents --- ## Code Example: Multi-Chain Token Purchase ```typescript // convex/mutations/tokens.ts export const purchase = confect.mutation({ args: { tokenId: v.id("entities"), amount: v.number(), network: v.optional(v.union(v.literal("sui"), v.literal("solana"), v.literal("base"))), }, handler: (ctx, args) => Effect.gen(function* () { const tokenService = yield* TokenService; const networkSelector = yield* NetworkSelector; // Auto-select optimal network if not specified const selectedNetwork = args.network || (yield* networkSelector.selectOptimalNetwork({ type: "token_purchase" })); // Purchase on selected network const result = yield* tokenService.purchase({ ...args, network: selectedNetwork, }); return { success: true, network: selectedNetwork, txDigest: result.txDigest, costUSD: result.costUSD, }; }).pipe(Effect.provide(MainLayer)), }); ``` --- ## Conclusion **The Verdict: SUI + Solana + Base Multi-Chain** The ONE Platform should deploy across three networks: 1. **SUI (Primary)** - Best overall for AI agents - Fastest finality (400ms) - Lowest cost ($0.00005/tx) - True parallel execution - Object model matches ontology perfectly 2. **Solana (Secondary)** - Mature ecosystem, proven scale - Equally fast finality - Massive AI ecosystem - Battle-tested at scale 3. **Base (Bridge)** - Ethereum access - DeFi integrations - USDC native - Enterprise on-ramps **Key Insight:** The 6-dimension ontology makes this trivial. Networks are just metadata. Build once, deploy everywhere. **This is how you build the fastest, cheapest, most scalable AI agent network in crypto.** --- ## Next Steps 1. **Read:** `one/Sui.md` for SUI integration patterns 2. **Build:** SUI provider in `convex/services/providers/sui.ts` 3. **Deploy:** First token contract on SUI testnet 4. **Expand:** Add Solana provider 5. **Bridge:** Connect SUI ↔ Solana ↔ Base 6. **Optimize:** AI-driven network selection **The future is multi-chain. The future is parallel. The future is ONE.**