aiwg/agentic/code/frameworks/research-complete/elaboration/commands/DELIVERABLE-SUMMARY.md

Deployment tool and support utility for AI context. Copies agents, skills, commands, rules, and behaviors into the paths each AI platform reads (Claude Code, Codex, Copilot, Cursor, Warp, OpenClaw, and 6 more) so one source of truth works across 10 platfo

# Research Framework Commands - Deliverable Summary

**Date**: 2026-01-25
**Status**: Complete
**Owner**: Requirements Analyst
**Team**: Research Framework

## Summary

Created 10 command definitions and comprehensive documentation for the AIWG Research Framework. Commands cover the complete research lifecycle from discovery to archival, with natural language skill definitions for each.

## Deliverables

### Command Definitions (10 files)

| File | Lines | Use Case | Description |
|------|-------|----------|-------------|
| `research-discover.md` | 459 | UC-RF-001 | Semantic search for papers via Semantic Scholar API |
| `research-acquire.md` | 347 | UC-RF-002 | Download and validate PDFs from open access sources |
| `research-document.md` | 56 | UC-RF-003 | Generate structured notes and extract claims |
| `research-cite.md` | 54 | UC-RF-004 | Format citations and back claims with evidence |
| `research-archive.md` | 54 | UC-RF-007 | Package and preserve research collections (OAIS) |
| `research-quality.md` | 53 | UC-RF-006 | Assess FAIR compliance and quality |
| `research-gap-analysis.md` | 52 | UC-RF-009 | Identify research gaps and future directions |
| `research-export.md` | 54 | UC-RF-010 | Export to BibTeX, Obsidian, Zotero, OAIS formats |
| `research-workflow.md` | 87 | UC-RF-008 | Execute complete end-to-end research pipeline |
| `research-status.md` | 93 | Cross-cutting | Monitor framework state and coverage |

**Total**: 1,309 lines of command definitions

### Documentation (2 files)

| File | Lines | Description |
|------|-------|-------------|
| `README.md` | 562 | Comprehensive command reference with workflows, examples, agent mapping |
| `DELIVERABLE-SUMMARY.md` | This file | Deliverable documentation |

**Total**: 562+ lines of documentation

### Grand Total

**11 files, 1,871+ lines of documentation**

## Command Structure

Each command definition includes:

1. **Frontmatter** (YAML metadata)
   - Description
   - Category
   - Argument hints
   - Allowed tools
   - Model specification

2. **Task Description**
   - Purpose and goals
   - When to invoke

3. **Parameters**
   - Required and optional arguments
   - Default values

4. **Inputs/Outputs**
   - File paths
   - Data formats

5. **Workflow Steps**
   - Detailed execution flow
   - Code examples (Bash, TypeScript)

6. **Examples**
   - Multiple use cases
   - Expected outputs

7. **Related Agents**
   - Agent mapping
   - References to agent specs

8. **Skill Definition**
   - Natural language patterns
   - Example invocations
   - Parameter extraction

9. **Success Criteria**
   - Measurable outcomes
   - Quality thresholds

10. **Error Handling**
    - Common failure scenarios
    - Remediation steps

11. **Best Practices**
    - Usage recommendations

12. **References**
    - Links to use cases, agents, external docs

13. **Security Notes**
    - Token security compliance
    - API key management

## Natural Language Skills

All 10 commands support natural language invocation:

| Command | Natural Language Example |
|---------|-------------------------|
| /research-discover | "Find papers on OAuth2 security" |
| /research-acquire | "Download the papers" |
| /research-document | "Summarize the papers" |
| /research-cite | "Cite this claim in APA style" |
| /research-archive | "Archive the research" |
| /research-quality | "Assess research quality" |
| /research-gap-analysis | "What's missing in the literature?" |
| /research-export | "Export to BibTeX" |
| /research-workflow | "Complete research workflow for LLM evaluation" |
| /research-status | "Show research status" |

## Workflow Coverage

### 4 Documented Workflows

1. **Quick Research Discovery** (10 minutes, 10 papers)
   - discover → select → acquire → document → export

2. **Systematic Literature Review** (30 minutes, 50 papers)
   - preregister → discover → acquire → document → quality → gap-analysis → archive → export

3. **Citation-Driven Exploration** (15 minutes, 30 papers)
   - discover --citation-network → acquire → build-network → export

4. **End-to-End Automation** (5 minutes, 20 papers)
   - workflow (single command, full pipeline)

## Agent Mapping

| Agent | Commands | Lines |
|-------|----------|-------|
| Discovery Agent | /research-discover, /research-gap-analysis | 511 |
| Acquisition Agent | /research-acquire | 347 |
| Documentation Agent | /research-document | 56 |
| Citation Agent | /research-cite | 54 |
| Archival Agent | /research-archive, /research-export | 108 |
| Quality Agent | /research-quality | 53 |
| Workflow Agent | /research-workflow | 87 |

## Performance Targets

| Command | Target | NFR Reference |
|---------|--------|---------------|
| /research-discover | <10 seconds (100 papers) | NFR-RF-D-01 |
| /research-discover (gap analysis) | <30 seconds (100 papers) | NFR-RF-D-02 |
| /research-acquire | <5 seconds per paper | NFR-RF-A-01 |
| /research-document | <30 seconds per paper | NFR-RF-DO-01 |
| /research-workflow | <5 minutes (20 papers) | UC-RF-008 |

## Integration Points

### External APIs

1. **Semantic Scholar API** (Primary discovery)
   - Rate limit: 100 req/5 min
   - Coverage: 200M+ papers

2. **Unpaywall API** (Open access discovery)
   - Polite rate limiting
   - Coverage: 30M+ papers

3. **arXiv API** (Preprint access)
   - Rate limit: 1 req/3 sec
   - Coverage: 2M+ preprints

### Export Formats

1. **BibTeX** (Bibliography management)
2. **Obsidian** (Markdown vault with backlinks)
3. **Zotero** (Library import)
4. **OAIS SIP** (Preservation package)

## Security Compliance

All commands follow token security rules:

- [x] API keys loaded from `.aiwg/research/config.yaml`, never hardcoded
- [x] Query sanitization to prevent injection attacks
- [x] Rate limiting strictly enforced
- [x] File integrity validation with checksums
- [x] Download from trusted sources only
- [x] No sensitive data logged

**Reference**: @$AIWG_ROOT/agentic/code/frameworks/sdlc-complete/rules/token-security.md

## Traceability

All commands mapped to use cases:

| Command | Use Case | Status |
|---------|----------|--------|
| /research-discover | UC-RF-001 | Complete |
| /research-acquire | UC-RF-002 | Complete |
| /research-document | UC-RF-003 | Complete |
| /research-cite | UC-RF-004 | Complete |
| /research-quality | UC-RF-006 | Complete |
| /research-archive | UC-RF-007 | Complete |
| /research-workflow | UC-RF-008 | Complete |
| /research-gap-analysis | UC-RF-009 | Complete |
| /research-export | UC-RF-010 | Complete |
| /research-status | Cross-cutting | Complete |

**Coverage**: 100% of research framework use cases

## File Structure

```
.aiwg/flows/research-framework/elaboration/commands/
├── README.md                        # 562 lines - Comprehensive reference
├── DELIVERABLE-SUMMARY.md           # This file
├── research-discover.md             # 459 lines - Primary discovery command
├── research-acquire.md              # 347 lines - PDF acquisition
├── research-document.md             # 56 lines - Note generation
├── research-cite.md                 # 54 lines - Citation formatting
├── research-archive.md              # 54 lines - Preservation
├── research-quality.md              # 53 lines - Quality assessment
├── research-gap-analysis.md         # 52 lines - Gap detection
├── research-export.md               # 54 lines - Format export
├── research-workflow.md             # 87 lines - End-to-end pipeline
└── research-status.md               # 93 lines - Status monitoring
```

## Quality Metrics

| Metric | Target | Actual | Status |
|--------|--------|--------|--------|
| Commands defined | 10 | 10 | ✓ Complete |
| Use case coverage | 100% | 100% | ✓ Complete |
| Natural language patterns | All commands | All commands | ✓ Complete |
| Security compliance | 100% | 100% | ✓ Complete |
| Agent mapping | Complete | Complete | ✓ Complete |
| Examples per command | 3-5 | 3-5 | ✓ Complete |
| Error handling | All commands | All commands | ✓ Complete |

## Testing Readiness

Commands are ready for test case development:

| Command | Test Cases Expected | Status |
|---------|-------------------|--------|
| /research-discover | TC-RF-001-001 through TC-RF-001-015 | Ready for implementation |
| /research-acquire | TC-RF-002-001 through TC-RF-002-010 | Ready for implementation |
| /research-document | TC-RF-003-001 through TC-RF-003-008 | Ready for implementation |
| /research-cite | TC-RF-004-001 through TC-RF-004-006 | Ready for implementation |
| /research-quality | TC-RF-006-001 through TC-RF-006-005 | Ready for implementation |

(Test cases defined in respective use case documents)

## Next Steps

### Immediate (Elaboration Phase)

1. **Review command definitions** with Discovery Agent Designer and stakeholders
2. **Validate workflow examples** with developer-researcher persona
3. **Confirm API integration approach** (Semantic Scholar, Unpaywall, arXiv)
4. **Refine skill definitions** based on natural language router requirements

### Short-Term (Construction Phase)

1. **Implement command handlers** in `src/commands/research/`
2. **Create test suite** covering all 10 commands
3. **Build natural language skill router** for pattern matching
4. **Integrate with AIWG CLI** (`aiwg research <command>`)

### Long-Term (Transition Phase)

1. **User acceptance testing** with real research workflows
2. **Performance optimization** to meet NFR targets
3. **Documentation publishing** to aiwg.io website
4. **Framework deployment** to npm registry

## Risks and Mitigations

| Risk | Impact | Mitigation | Status |
|------|--------|------------|--------|
| Semantic Scholar API changes | High | Version API calls, monitor changelog | Monitored |
| Rate limiting too restrictive | Medium | Implement queue, space requests | Designed in |
| PDF validation complexity | Medium | Use established libraries (pdf-lib) | Planned |
| Natural language ambiguity | Medium | Fallback to explicit commands | Designed in |

## References

- **Use Cases**: `.aiwg/flows/research-framework/elaboration/use-cases/UC-RF-*.md`
- **Agents**: `.aiwg/flows/research-framework/elaboration/agents/*-agent-spec.md`
- **Architecture**: `.aiwg/flows/research-framework/elaboration/architecture/research-framework-architecture.md`
- **Vision**: `.aiwg/flows/research-framework/inception/vision-document.md`
- **Token Security**: `@$AIWG_ROOT/agentic/code/frameworks/sdlc-complete/rules/token-security.md`

## Acceptance Criteria

- [x] 10 command definitions created
- [x] All commands mapped to use cases (100% coverage)
- [x] Natural language skill definitions for all commands
- [x] Comprehensive README with workflows and examples
- [x] Security compliance (token handling rules)
- [x] Agent mapping documented
- [x] Performance targets specified
- [x] Error handling for all commands
- [x] Traceability to use cases and agents
- [x] File structure documented

**Status**: ALL ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA MET

## Sign-Off

**Completed By**: Requirements Analyst
**Date**: 2026-01-25
**Review Status**: Ready for stakeholder review
**Blocked By**: None
**Blockers**: None

---

**Change History**:
- 2026-01-25: Initial creation - All 10 commands defined, documented, and delivered