@endgame-build/claude-workflows/.claude/templates/review.template.md

Claude Code workflow system with commands, agents, and templates for AI-native development

# Code Review Summary Template

Use this template to present code review findings consistently across review commands.

## Review Findings

### Critical Issues (Must Fix)
[List each issue with file:line references and explanation]
- **[Issue Type]**: [Description] (`file:line`)
  - Why: [Explanation of the risk/problem]
  - Fix: [Suggested solution]

### Major Concerns (Should Fix)
[List significant issues that should be addressed]
- **[Concern Type]**: [Description] (`file:line`)
  - Impact: [Potential consequences]
  - Suggestion: [Recommended approach]

### Minor Suggestions (Consider)
[List improvements that would enhance code quality]
- **[Category]**: [Description] (`file:line`)
  - Benefit: [Why this would help]

## Compliance Analysis

### Security Analysis
- **Authentication**: ✅/❌ [Details of auth implementation]
- **Authorization**: ✅/❌ [Access control assessment]
- **Input Validation**: ✅/❌ [Data sanitization status]
- **Security Best Practices**: ✅/❌ [Following security standards]
- **Secrets Management**: ✅/❌ [No hardcoded secrets]

### Architecture Compliance
- **Separation of Concerns**: ✅/❌ [Clear layer boundaries]
- **Service Isolation**: ✅/❌ [Proper service boundaries]
- **Design Patterns**: ✅/❌ [Appropriate pattern usage]
- **Environment Support**: ✅/❌ [Platform compatibility]
- **Dependencies**: ✅/❌ [Proper dependency management]

### Code Standards Compliance
- **Language Conventions**: ✅/❌ [Following language idioms]
- **Import/Export Style**: ✅/❌ [Module system compliance]
- **Naming Conventions**: ✅/❌ [Consistent naming]
- **Code Organization**: ✅/❌ [Logical file structure]
- **Error Handling**: ✅/❌ [Consistent error patterns]

### Type Safety Analysis
- **Type System Usage**: ✅/❌ [Proper type definitions and usage]
- **Type Flow Integrity**: ✅/❌ [Types consistent throughout]
- **Validation Compliance**: ✅/❌ [Input/output validation]
- **Contract Adherence**: ✅/❌ [API contracts respected]
- **Type Safety**: ✅/❌ [No unsafe type operations]

### Performance Analysis

- **Algorithm Efficiency**: [Complexity analysis]
- **Resource Usage**: [Memory/CPU considerations]
- **Scalability**: [Performance under load]
- **Optimization**: [Caching, batching status]

### Implementation Quality Analysis

- **Async Safety**: ✅/❌ [Proper async/await patterns]
- **State Management**: ✅/❌ [Clean state handling]
- **Configuration**: ✅/❌ [Externalized configuration]
- **Error Propagation**: ✅/❌ [Consistent error handling]
- **API Compliance**: ✅/❌ [Response format consistency]

### Resource Management Analysis

- **Connection Handling**: ✅/❌ [Resources properly released]
- **Memory Management**: ✅/❌ [No memory leaks]
- **Cleanup Logic**: ✅/❌ [Proper cleanup on errors]
- **Transaction Scope**: ✅/❌ [Atomic operations]
- **Resource Limits**: ✅/❌ [Bounded resource usage]

### Testing Analysis

- **Test Coverage**: ✅/❌ [Critical paths tested]
- **Test Quality**: ✅/❌ [Meaningful test cases]
- **Edge Cases**: ✅/❌ [Boundary conditions tested]
- **Error Scenarios**: ✅/❌ [Failure cases tested]
- **Integration Tests**: ✅/❌ [System integration verified]

## Overall Assessment

### Compliance Score: X/10

- Security: X/10
- Architecture: X/10
- Code Quality: X/10
- Performance: X/10
- Testing: X/10

### Risk Level: [Low/Medium/High]

[Explanation of risk assessment based on findings]

### Action Items

- [ ] Address all critical issues before merge
- [ ] Fix major concerns identified
- [ ] Ensure all tests pass
- [ ] Update documentation if needed
- [ ] Verify no breaking changes or document them

### Recommendation

[✅ Approve / ⚠️ Approve with changes / ❌ Request changes]
[Brief explanation of the recommendation]